Reluctatnly, Paul and Maureen agree to sell her in order to send their uncle to college. Buy how will they fill the empty hole? Finding an orphan foal helps, and Sea Star needs them as much as they need her.

Pony penning day holds a surprise for everyone, for Paul did not only bring in the Phantom, but her newborn foal. too. Can Paul and Maureen possibly earn enough to buy them both? A tale of the Chincoteague Pony auction, still an annual event on the island